Skip to content
View all posts

Scams, Breaches and Bank Outages: Straight Talk From Our Fraud Team

By: Jill Franks

Apple Spotify YouTube

On Monday, November 16th, I received a letter in the mail from one of my favorite online clothing stores. I was hoping for a Black Friday coupon. Instead, it was a data breach notice telling me my personal information may have been exposed, and I should freeze my credit.

If you've gotten a letter like that, you're not alone. Breaches seem to happen more often every year. Add this week's headlines about big banks going offline, and a lot of people are asking the same question: is my money safe?

On this episode of Isn't That Rich, I sat down with the people at Farmers State Bank who fight fraud every single day:

  • Doug Williams, Information Security Officer, who focuses on protecting information and understanding the threats we face
  • Troy Graham, Vice President of Electronic Banking, who works with the digital banking systems criminals love to target
  • Christine Hankins, President of Retail Banking, who works closely with the teams helping customers through suspicious activity and fraud

Here's what they wanted you to know.

Is My Money Safe?

Yes. Farmers State Bank is FDIC insured, so your deposits are protected.

Christine cleared up a common misunderstanding. Many people think FDIC coverage stops at $250,000 per person, per bank. In reality, coverage depends on how your accounts are titled. Different ownership categories are insured separately, so accounts with joint owners or named beneficiaries can be covered well beyond $250,000. An IRA, for example, falls in its own category with its own coverage.

Want to check your own accounts? The FDIC has a free calculator called EDIE where you enter how your accounts are titled and the balances, with no account numbers needed. Our branch team is also happy to walk through it with you. For customers who need even more coverage, we partner with IntraFi Network to extend FDIC insurance into the millions.

One important note: FDIC insurance protects you if a bank fails. It doesn't cover money lost to fraud, which is why the rest of this conversation matters so much.

What about the outages? Network and website outages aren't as unusual as the headlines make them seem. They happen at banks of every size, including ours. Many large banks rely on the same few cloud providers, so one problem can ripple out to a lot of institutions at once. During this week's outages, customers' money stayed put. People just couldn't see it for a while.

We've had customers come in worried and withdraw large amounts of cash. We understand the instinct, but your money is safest right where it is.

Your Best Fraud Tools Are Already in Your App

Troy's first piece of advice: check your online banking often. "At the end of the day, you're your best protection," he said. A few tools make that easier.

  • Turn on alerts. Our mobile app can notify you every time your debit card is used or money moves in or out of your account.
  • Use a digital wallet. Apple Pay and Samsung Pay mask your real debit card number. If a store gets breached, thieves don't get your actual card.
  • Pay bills through online banking. Every paper check you write carries your account and routing numbers. When our bill pay mails a check for you, those numbers aren't printed on it, so a stolen envelope doesn't expose your account.
  • Lock your card in seconds. If something looks off, you can turn your debit card off right from the app.

Mail theft is a real problem. Doug explained that master keys for postal boxes are sold online, letting thieves open every mailbox in an apartment complex at once. Stolen checks get "washed" and rewritten.

Our team also monitors the dark web. When we spot an FSB debit card number for sale, we lock it down and get the customer a new card before any fraudulent charges hit.

Those daily spending limits on your card? They're there to protect you too. If you need to make a big purchase, you can raise your limit in the app.

Never Share Your Code

Those one-time codes you get when paying a bill or logging in can feel like a hassle. They're there so that even if someone gets into your online banking, they can't start sending your money out.

That's why scammers want them so badly. One of the most common tricks right now is spoofing. A fraudster calls, and your caller ID shows the bank's real number. They say there's fraud on your account and ask you to read them the code so they can "stop it." You're panicked, you see the bank's number, and you hand it over, even though the text itself says not to share it with anyone, not even your bank.

Here's the fix: hang up and call us back on the number you know is ours. If you'd rather not hang up, just say you need to step away and you'll call right back. With a community bank, you'll reach a real person quickly, and we'll never be offended. In fact, our team says they're proud of customers who do it.

When a link or a code request lands in your lap, try the nine-second rule. Take nine seconds to breathe and ask yourself whether this is legit. Scammers are counting on you not to pause.

Scams Are Getting Smarter

Doug sees the newest tricks first, and AI is speeding everything up. It's helping companies find security flaws faster than ever, which is good news. Criminals have the same tools, though.

Fake login pages. You might get an email saying you have a forwarded voicemail, with a link to listen. The link takes you to a page that looks exactly like a Microsoft login. Once you sign in, criminals can grab your session and get into your account without ever needing your password or a verification code. Doug has seen this happen twice personally. The same goes for banking: with AI, a scammer can copy a bank's website in seconds.

The safest habit is simple. Don't click links to log in. Open the FSB app or type the website address yourself.

Passkeys are coming. More sites now offer passkeys in place of passwords. A fake website can't fool a passkey, so whenever a site offers one, Doug says to use it.

One missing letter. Doug shared a story about a local business that got an email from a vendor asking to update its wiring instructions. The email address was missing a single letter. Over a few months, the business sent somewhere around $50,000 to $60,000 to the scammers before the real vendor called asking where its payments were. If anyone emails you new payment instructions, call that company on a number you already have before sending a dime.

Scammers can also be patient. Once they're in your email, they may watch quietly for a year or two, learning who you pay and when, before they strike.

Scams Hitting Close to Home

Christine and her branch teams see fraud face to face, and many of these stories happened right here in Southern Illinois.

You can't trust a voice anymore. AI can make a scammer sound exactly like your loved one. Christine suggests picking a secret word only your family knows. If someone calls claiming to be in trouble, ask for the word.

Spoofed police calls. It isn't only the bank's number that gets faked. Scammers have spoofed the Marion and Harrisburg police departments, along with the IRS. Their first goal is to scare you. If a call makes you panic, hang up and call the police station or your bank directly.

Grandparent scams. We recently saw two successful grandparent scams locally. In one, the "grandchild" had been in an accident and needed money. In the other, a caller claimed a grandson was arrested for DUI and the charges could be reduced if money was sent. One call to the real grandchild would have stopped both. We've even had a customer mail cash because they were so frightened.

Scams that ride the headlines. When Microsoft had its recent outage, scammers sent emails with links to "reset your Microsoft password." After the Marion tornado, fake contractors showed up offering repairs. In Harrisburg, a few young contractors were recently tricked into paying fraudsters for a job on a condemned house and lost thousands. Before hiring anyone or buying a car, check the business on the Better Business Bureau. We're happy to look it up with you.

Charity calls. With Christmas coming, expect calls asking for donations. Legitimate charities must register with the Illinois Attorney General's office, so you can check them there. Better yet, ask them to send their information by mail. If a caller pushes urgency, that's a red flag.

Gift cards. If anyone asks you to pay with gift cards, it's a scam. Every time. That includes your boss. One of our customers, a teacher, got an early morning text from someone claiming to be her principal asking her to buy gift cards right away. She bought them, but a gut feeling stopped her from sending the photos. That instinct saved her money.

Talk to Your Kids About Sextortion

Fraud isn't only an older person's problem. Some of the most heartbreaking cases involve teenagers, especially high school boys.

Scammers pose as someone their age and keep the conversation going until the teen sends a photo. Then the blackmail starts, with demands that can reach several thousand dollars. To a high schooler, that feels impossible. Many are too afraid and embarrassed to tell their parents, and tragically, some of these cases have ended in suicide.

The best protection is a conversation before it ever happens. Let your kids know they can come to you, no matter what, and they won't be in trouble. Pay attention to the apps they use and who they're talking to, especially if one new name keeps coming up.

If it does happen, don't pay. Save the messages and report the account, then get help. The National Center for Missing & Exploited Children offers Take It Down, a free tool to help remove explicit images, and you can reach them at 1-800-THE-LOST. If your child is struggling, call or text 988 for the Suicide & Crisis Lifeline.

Adults get targeted with similar threats too, such as claims that you visited a certain website or that something was planted on your computer. Whatever the threat, don't stay quiet. Talk to your bank or the police. It happens to more people than you'd think.

Steps You Can Take This Week

It's easy to think, "My information is already out there, so why bother?" Our panel disagreed. A few simple habits make you a much harder target.

See where you've been exposed. Visit Have I Been Pwned and enter your email address. It shows every known breach your email has turned up in. When I tried it, my personal email showed up in 17. Change the passwords for any account listed.

Stop reusing passwords. When criminals find one password, they try it on a dozen other sites. Doug recommends a passphrase, a short sentence that's easy for you to remember, or the password manager already built into your phone or browser. Your debit card PIN deserves the same care. Skip your birth year or any number a thief could find in your wallet.

Start with what matters most. Change your bank password and PIN today. Tomorrow, move to the next most important account and turn on multi-factor authentication.

Freeze your credit. A freeze keeps anyone from opening a loan or credit card in your name. It's free at all three credit bureaus: Equifax, Experian and TransUnion. Go straight to their sites, since many search results are third parties, and never enter a card number because a freeze shouldn't cost you anything. You can still use your existing cards, and you can lift the freeze anytime you need a new loan. If you'd like help, stop by any FSB branch and we can get it done in about 10 minutes. While you're at it, pull your free credit reports at AnnualCreditReport.com.

Let unknown calls go to voicemail. Most phones can send calls from numbers not in your contacts straight to voicemail. Real callers leave a message. If someone claims to be from your bank, call back on the number you know, not the one that called you. Be careful with search results too. Doug's mother-in-law once called a fake Amazon number she found online, so go to the company's official website for its phone number.

Lock down your social media. Set your profiles to private and turn on multi-factor authentication. Hacked accounts are used to scam your friends and family, like the fake concert tickets and "estate sale" hot tub our panel has seen sold through friends' hacked Facebook pages. Once an account is gone, it's very hard to get back.

Check out as a guest. When you shop online, skip creating an account and use Apple Pay or Samsung Pay when you can. The less a store stores about you, the less there is to steal.

Update and restart. Software updates fix security holes, so turn on automatic updates. Restart your phone and computer about once a week so those updates actually install.

Why We Ask Questions

If you come in to send a wire or withdraw a large amount of cash, our team may ask a lot of questions. We're not being nosy, and we're not short on cash. Our front line has seen these scams up close, and those questions are how we catch fraud before your money is gone. Wire fraud in particular is the big frontier right now.

The same goes for check holds. Many people assume checks clear instantly. In reality, it takes at least four days for a bank to learn that a check has been returned. A hold makes sure you're not out the money if that check turns out to be bad.

For business customers, Positive Pay is another strong tool against check fraud. Ask us and we'll help you get set up.

The Bottom Line

In nearly every fraud case our team has handled, the scammer got in because someone shared a code. Troy put it best: the bank keeps your house locked, but handing over your verification code is like giving a burglar the key. Once they're inside, there's only so much we can do.

So take a breath. Nothing has to be done right this second. Hang up and call someone you know. Going back to that old-fashioned habit would stop a lot of fraud in its tracks.

If something ever feels off, call us or stop by any Farmers State Bank location in Alto Pass, Harrisburg, Marion or Herrin. You'll talk to a real person who knows you, and we're always glad to help.